Fake cigars become burning legal issue
The nation's biggest cigar maker has been on a mission to put suspected Cuban cigar counterfeiters from Little Havana to Hialeah out of business.
Fort Lauderdale-based Altadis U.S.A. paid tens of thousands of dollars to fund part of an undercover Miami-Dade Police probe of five suspects charged with trafficking in counterfeit cigars, court records show.
The first of three federal trials, set for today, raises controversial issues about the integrity of the investigation, the fake Cuban cigar market, and the U.S. trade embargo against the Castro government.
The police department, which normally funds its own investigations, said Monday it could not comment on Altadis' role in the probe because its legal department had not reviewed the matter and also because it involves a federal case. The U.S. attorney's office declined to comment. Altadis U.S.A. executives did not return two calls Monday.
Coral Gables lawyer Frank Quintero, who represents a defendant facing trial later this month, accused Altadis of trying to ''buy'' a criminal investigation from police for one purpose: to crush the alleged counterfeiters so the company can monopolize the U.S. market for Cuban cigars after Fidel Castro dies.
''It calls into question the impartiality of an investigation when witnesses including an informant are being paid by a private party that claims to be an alleged victim in the case,'' Quintero said.
Altadis U.S.A. fronted at least $17,750 to police for five undercover ''buys'' of allegedly fake Cuban cigars, boxes and labeling materials in three separate cases. Police returned about $4,000 in unused money.
Altadis also footed the bill for hauling away and storing seized materials for the upcoming trials, court records show.
The company also directly paid an informant who assisted Miami-Dade detectives in the undercover transactions, according to lawyers for the defense and court records. Altadis paid the informant $1,500 a week and other consulting fees from July 2005 until September 2006 -- plus $19,694 in relocation expenses.
The confidential source -- identified in federal court as Leonard V. Gutierrez -- was hand-delivered by Altadis executives to Miami-Dade investigators, court records show. Gutierrez himself is a former alleged Cuban cigar counterfeiter who won a $15.4 million Florida Lottery prize in 1992.
Investigators turned down Altadis' offer to pay for police overtime and other expenses, according to records.
E-mails show that detectives and federal prosecutors kept Altadis in the loop on the status of the investigation. A prosecutor in the U.S. Attorney's Office told Altadis' lawyers, an Altadis private investigator and police exactly when he was going to present the counterfeit indictments to the Miami federal grand jury last March, emails show.
In court papers, Altadis claims it holds the exclusive license for the U.S. trademarks for the famous Cuban cigar brands Montecristo, H. Upmann, Por Larranaga, Romeo y Julieta, Saint Luis Rey and Trinidad. Altadis holds those rights because its parent company, based in Spain, bought them from Cuba's exiled cigar-baron families decades after Castro's revolution in 1959.
The parent company, Altadis S.A., which now controls half the Castro government's cigar entity, says it avoids any violation of the U.S. trade embargo by selling Cuban-made cigars in Europe and by using the Fort Lauderdale subsidiary to sell Dominican Republic-made cigars in the United States.
Altadis executives and their trademark lawyers claim ''unlawful counterfeiting of these cigar brands is rampant in Miami-Dade County.'' They originally brought the case to the attention of Miami-Dade police and the state attorney's office last year.
In a sworn statement, Altadis U.S.A. marketing vice president Eric Workman said the wholesale price of its ''genuine'' Dominican-made Montecristo and Romeo y Julieta brand cigars -- the two most widely counterfeited brands -- is $75 to $125 per box. The average retail price per box is $125 to $250, he said.
Workman estimated that a Miami-Dade counterfeiter of 1,000 boxes deprives Altadis U.S.A. of $150,000 to $200,000 in sales.
'That the counterfeit packaging material indicates Cuba as the country-of-origin for the counterfeit cigars further tarnishes our marks and misleads the public by implying that the Cubans are the true owners of the Montecristo, H. Upmann, Por Larranaga, Romeo Y Julieta, Saint Luis Rey and Trinidad trademarks and that our cigars are `counterfeits' or 'fakes,' '' Workman wrote in December 2005.
But defense attorneys for the five Miami-Dade suspects charged with counterfeiting Altadis' cigar brands counter their clients' counterfeit cigars and boxes are modeled after actual brands that have been made and sold by the Cuban government's Habanos S.A. since it nationalized the cigar industry in 1961.
As such, they claim their clients' products are not violating Altadis' U.S. trademarks for its Cuban-replica cigars sold in this country because the counterfeits' boxes say ''made in Cuba'' on them.
`THE LITTLE FISH'
Moreover, the defense lawyers assert that Altadis cannot protect its Cuban cigar trademarks in the United States because of the U.S. trade embargo. They argue that their clients -- who obtain their tobacco from Honduras and package their ''Cuban'' cigars in Miami-Dade -- cannot be charged with counterfeiting products with trademarks that do not legally exist in the United States.
''Prosecutors are going after the little fish when the big fish is in downtown Fort Lauderdale,'' said Coral Gables attorney Jose ''Pepe'' Herrera, whose client, Hialeah cigar box maker Juan Penton, faces trial today.
Herrera claims Altadis U.S.A. -- through its parent company in Spain -- is violating the U.S. trade embargo by using actual Cuban cigar trademarks to sell Cuban-replica cigars in the United States.
''So who is the ultimate counterfeiter?'' Herrera said.
He added that the alleged five counterfeiters actually sell cigars that buyers know to be a ''novelty,'' not the real thing. He stressed the defendants are not being charged with selling fraudulent products.
Quintero, who represents Little Havana cigar seller Feliberto Marimon, said Altadis U.S.A. should be the one under federal scrutiny. ''They're the ones who did the agreement with the Cuban government,'' he said.
Today's trial is likely to spark verbal fireworks.
During a Sept. 12 pretrial hearing, U.S. District Judge Federico Moreno poked fun at a federal prosecutor, saying the U.S. attorney's office was treating the cigar counterfeit case like a major cocaine-smuggling prosecution.
Moreno also jabbed assistant U.S. attorney Michael Gilfarb, who took over the case last month, for avoiding any mention of the ''C word'' -- as in Cuba -- while describing Altadis U.S.A.'s cigar brands.
At one point in the hearing, Gilfarb declared: ``Cuba is the third party here. There is no evidence to show Altadis U.S.A. is benefiting Cuba.''
The judge will have the final say on that issue at trial.
Source: Miami Herald